Should Resource Specific Zones allow upgrades?

Discussion and questions regarding the game rules
Mercury
Mercury
Chriz
Praetorian Empire
Brend
Veolian Commonwealth
Gerben
Sundarian Federation
The Lifebringer Clans
The Lifebringer Clans

Should Resource Specific Zones allow upgrades

Yes
0
No votes
No
2
67%
Other (see text)
1
33%
 
Total votes : 3

User avatar
Mercury
Storyteller
 
At the current time, resource specific zones (such as those generated by Gas Giants, Asteroid Belts, Rings and Trojan Asteroids) do not allow upgrades.

Do you believe it would be better to allow upgrades for these zones? This would make these (cheap) zones more useful though they would still not be as useful as zones on regular planets, which are more versatile and can benefit from focus and tertiary zones.

Please feel free to post your thoughts on the topic.
Post Praetorian Empire » Thu May 19, 2011 7:36 pm
User avatar
Praetorian Empire
Faction
 
Since the metal zones only cost half the rock i don't think upgrades should be appropriate. Because u can only boost metal and gasses with those it would probably become unbalanced.
For gass giants it might be ok to let them upgrade since they cost 1 gass for each zone.
Post Veolian Commonwealth » Thu May 19, 2011 8:21 pm
User avatar
Veolian Commonwealth
Faction
 
Voted no. I think that upgrading the normal way should not be allowed; at least part of those specific zones are there because they cost less in terms of solar-system-budget. It think that each of these specific zones has a limited amount of accessable resource, and that amount is not suddenly increased by spending taxes. Unless one says that the extraction process is made that much more efficient by upgrading, but to me that would indicate that a coorporation should also be able to specialise the zone.

Side Note @Chris: Is 'you' or 'one' that much more effort than 'u'?
Post Sundarian Federation » Thu May 19, 2011 10:22 pm
User avatar
Sundarian Federation
Faction
 
I second the argument Chris makes here, these zones are already cheaper then the 'normal' zones through systembuilding. The restriction that these zones therefore can't be upgraded seems a good way to balance this.
Post Praetorian Empire » Thu May 19, 2011 10:40 pm
User avatar
Praetorian Empire
Faction
 
@Brend, Yes u are right, 2 extra letters!
Post Mercury » Sat May 28, 2011 10:16 am
User avatar
Mercury
Storyteller
 
Poll closed. Resource Specific Zones will not allow upgrades.
Post The Lifebringer Clans » Mon Jun 13, 2011 11:20 am
User avatar
The Lifebringer Clans
Faction
 
Do resource Specific Zones allow specialization through corporations?

Return to Game Questions

cron